Chris Pollinger shares brokerage budget planning truths every real estate business must face to cut comfort, measure performance and prioritize profit.
Most brokers won’t admit it, but their brokerage budget planning process is really just an annual guessing game dressed up in spreadsheets and optimism. They throw money at the same broken systems, keep the same underperformers and call it “investing in growth.”
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL SURVEY FOR OCTOBER
It’s not growth. It’s financial self-sabotage.
By all accounts, 2026 is shaping up to be another survival year. Rising costs, unpredictable markets and tightening margins are exposing who’s actually running a business — and who’s just running tabs. The brokerages that win next year will be the ones that stop budgeting like accountants and start budgeting like strategists.
9 brutal brokerage budget planning truths
Here are nine brutal budgeting truths that’ll separate the survivors from the soon-to-be-acquired.
1. Comfort is the most expensive line item in your budget
Every brokerage overspends somewhere — usually on comfort. Legacy systems that “work fine,” underperforming agents who “just need more time,” or perks that look good on Instagram. Comfort kills profitability faster than any market shift.
If it doesn’t drive growth or retention, it’s dead weight. Be ruthless. The goal isn’t to cut — it’s to clarify.
2. Your marketing isn’t failing — your measurement is
Too many brokers confuse activity with effectiveness. You don’t need more marketing; you need marketing that actually converts.
If you can’t tie spend to measurable lead flow, reputation lift or revenue, you’re throwing cash into the void. Companies that invest more than 10 percent of their media budgets in marketing performance measurement are three times more likely to outgrow their growth plans by 25 percent, according to a study by Forbes CMO Practice and Neustar.
Stop chasing impressions. Start tracking conversions.
3. Audit your tech stack like it owes you money
Most brokerages run overlapping platforms because nobody wants to kill the tools they picked. You don’t need 10 CRMs, five automation systems and three “AI-powered” lead gen platforms.
If fewer than 30 percent of your agents use it, it’s not a tech stack — it’s a tax.
Do a usage audit quarterly. Replace redundancy with systems that actually reduce human labor.
4. Don’t budget for headcount — budget for performance
The 2026 brokerage isn’t about how many agents you have; it’s about how profitable each one is. Brokerages that reward body count are bleeding margin.
Invest in your top 20 percent. Give them premium resources, personal marketing budgets and high-level coaching. Let the rest self-select out. Your profitability will climb while your payroll drops.
5. Forecast like a cynic, operate like a realist
Too many brokers still budget as if the market owes them stability. Newsflash: It doesn’t.
Build three financial models for 2026 — best case, likely case and disaster case. The discipline of running “what-if” scenarios forces operational resilience. As Harvard Business Review notes in its crisis management framework, the companies that survive volatility are those that pre-commit to how they’ll respond when it hits.
You can’t predict the storm, but you can design your umbrella before it rains.
6. Automation isn’t about looking modern — it’s about replacing payroll
There’s a quiet revolution happening in back-end brokerage operations. Transaction management, lead routing and compliance tasks are being eaten by automation.
If your automation doesn’t remove human workload, it’s not automation — it’s theater.
Replace, don’t supplement. The cost of an automation platform should be offset by what you no longer need to pay people to do.
7. Brand spending without brand substance is just noise
Luxury brokerages, in particular, waste fortunes on brand aesthetics that have no backbone. A clean logo and expensive photoshoot won’t fix a reputation built on inconsistency.
Budget for substance before shine. Your brand is whatever your agents consistently deliver. Not what your creative team posts on Thursdays.
That means allocating money to leadership training, ethical standards and mentorship programs that make your agents better, not just prettier online.
8. Reward profit, not volume
In 2026, commission volume means nothing if your net margin is garbage. Too many brokerages brag about gross numbers and hide the truth in their P&Ls.
Make profit the scoreboard. Tie bonuses and incentives to efficiency and margin, not sales vanity. When profit becomes the hero metric, decision-making sharpens overnight.
9. Pay yourself like an owner — or admit you’re just an employee
If your brokerage can’t afford to pay you a return above your salary, it’s not a business. It’s a job you fund.
Build owner distributions into your budget. Separate them from payroll. If that forces hard cuts elsewhere, good. That’s what business discipline looks like.
The reward for risk should be profit, not exhaustion.
Most brokers will read this, nod along and then go right back to their bloated spreadsheets and “growth plans” instead of crafting an action-oriented brokerage budget planning process. That’s fine. The market needs mediocrity — it keeps the top tier looking smart.
But for the brokers ready to actually build sustainable, profitable enterprises in 2026, the playbook is simple:
- Eliminate comfort.
- Measure everything.
- Reward profit.
The rest? Noise.
The future of brokerage belongs to those willing to budget like owners, not optimists.
